Sounds like an odd lawsuit. Incapable? JK, are you and Debbie related or are you her defense attorney?
tennispro

JK it looks like you made the originial post about the case.Putting it on a public forum makes it open to public interest and discussion.At the top of this page it says TBC FORUM A place where Discussion is Welcome.
I wonder if you have ever thought about writing a book on your life ?? Personally I couldn't handle all the Drama. It might make interesting reading for some folks.

Tennis Pro and Rambling Man, as usual JK is only is telling ‘part’ of the story:

TP. If you don't know the answer to that question, then you are less informed than you appear to be. The ONLY odd lawsuit filed is the one filed by the Kimbels, false accusations.

Unless you are a party, then you don't have any direct knowledge, and I would suggest you keep some comments to yourself or be subpoenaed, deposed, and brought before a judge to tell exactly why you have such and interest in the case.

Both the Dye lawsuit against the Kimbels, and the Kimbel Counter Lawsuit are now "Public Record" which does give you THAT RIGHT to ask questions. By JK's own words to you, it's clear he is a party and does have direct knowledge.

What JK did not tell you is that earlier in the week Debbie Dye filed a Civil Lawsuit against the victim, the injured Mrs. Dreena Kimbel, a 72 year old retired Federal Court employee from California, and her step daughter Linda for “filing a false police report, and libel and slander”. Debbie Dye filed the suit herself, in General Sessions Civil Court, without an attorney representing her and is asking for $10,000 in damages.

Benton County was only named in the lawsuit this week because Debbie Dye filed the first lawsuit and it had to be answered. Yes, Dreena Kimbel is and was interviewing Plaintiff’s attorneys while waiting for her old medical records to be compared to new MRI’s, Xrays and the expert medical evaluation by her Doctors. Her injuries from that incident in early February had caused her to have to use a walker and cane and be on pain medication, so there was no question some injury had occurred but the total extent of injuries was still being evaluated. Would she have eventually sued Debbie Dye and the County? Probably, but Debbie Dye suing her and her step daughter first was the impetus for the Countersuit and Cross Complaints at this time.

Dreena Kimbel and Linda Kimbel were served with the Debbie Dye Lawsuit on Tuesday evening April 19th. They were preparing to leave on a out of State trip, planned months ago, so they immediately answered the Debbie Dye lawsuit the following day. Having to proactively file an answer, they decided to counter sue for the injuries Dreena Kimbel had received, suing Debbie Dye, and also filed a cross complaint against Joe Kyle who from their investigation had ordered Dye to enter that room and ‘break up that meeting' and also against the County because this occurred on County property, by County Officials, a Commissioner and a Beer Board Member, and was from the perspective and statements of the assailants, related to County Business.

The fact is that the matter is still under investigation and perhaps only a law enforcement entity can make the charge of ‘filing a false police report’ against someone. The Slander and Libel is alleged to be the fact there was dozens of people in the Courtroom adjacent to this small meeting room that were present when this occurred. Dreena Kimbel had asked to speak to Attorney Al Ward after the meeting he had been attending with several Commissioners and others at the Court House.

Al Ward had asked Dreena Kimbel and her step daughter to step into a small private meeting room adjacent to the Courtroom. Once they were seated, almost immediately the door of that room burst open with as many as 8-9 people headed up by Debbie Dye entered the room and allegedly Debbie Dye ‘bulldogged’ the much smaller and older Dreena Kimbel causing injury to her ankle. Debbie Dye then ordered Attorney Al Ward to leave the room stating something like ‘You work for us”.

The Kimbels only had Al Ward in the room as a witness. Mrs. Dreena Kimbel did not even know who Debbie Dye was nor did she know if there were other beer board members besides Kyle, and which specific County Commissioners entered the room. Therefore they put out a flyer asking for witnesses to the incident to come forward. In the Dye v. Kimbels lawsuit that was what is alleged to be the libel and slander.

You see the same thing quite often when there is an auto accident and the parties seek public ads to find witnesses. Libel and Slander for seeking witnesses?

Debbie Dye’s lawsuit started it.

Her $10,000 lawsuit against Dreena Kimbel and her step-daughter brought about the $300,000 lawsuit naming Benton County.

I think if you get a copy of both the original Debbie Dye suit, and the Kimbel counter suit, you will find these to be facts to be argued in Court, not on this forum.

I didn't post the information to be ridiculed, and the entire matter is far from hilarious.

Those who choose to look at the matter with a biased eye miss the true tragedy of the situation. You have sufficient facts to investigate the whole list of filings yourself. I gave you a full perspective to look at and have nothing further of value to contribute, and will not engage in an argument with anyone.

Thanks to those who see the big picture.

I would like to know why you are supporting the Kimbles so much, what have you to gain in it. I am not supporting either of them, yet you seem extremely interested in the Kimble side.
Yes I have read it and what I read is so bizarre, I just can't see anyone doing what Ms.Dye is accused of but you seem to know an awful lot of the story, you are not biased are you? Maybe you are her lawyer, yes/no,I can hardly wait to see the outcome of it all.
I am not smart enough to discuss these things with lawyers like you, so I will just wait for the courts to decide.

ONE reason the DYE/KIMBEL Lawsuits should be important to everybody in Benton County is because, the next time it could be you! It might not be over the same issue or happen in the same way, but make no mistake about it, it could happen to you, just as easily as as it happened to somebody else! None of us are immune. And you never know when you might have a reason to interact with the County Attorney or Members or Member of the County Commission, especially if you are trying to earn a Living in this County or have a business here.
If no action is taken to get to the bottom of this, can you honestly say that it would never happen to you?

[quote=NoFool}ONE reason the DYE/KIMBEL Lawsuits should be important to everybody in Benton County is because, the next time it could be you! It might not be over the same issue or happen in the same way, but make no mistake about it, it could happen to you, just as easily as as it happened to somebody else! None of us are immune. And you never know when you might have a reason to interact with the County Attorney or Members or Member of the County Commission, especially if you are trying to earn a Living in this County or have a business here.
If no action is taken to get to the bottom of this, can you honestly say that it would never happen to you?[/quote]

Linda as usual you follow your pimps lead when you don't know what you are talking about. You can tell your lies and spew your BS all over Topix but this forum is for grown ups to speak and as usual you have no idea what you are talking about. All you see is you hate Joe Kyle so anything even remotely associated with him is bad. This commission is worse then your beloved Jimmy Thornton's only because they appointed to to a board even though Jimmy and the majority of those commissions were crooks. Your hatred blinds you to any reason or facts.

Thank you, John, that's very kind of you & very much appreciated.

ROFLMAO@U You attempt to chastise me and question my credibility when you can't even get the simple facts straight much less your own story straight because it continuously changes yet mine stays the same I wonder why? Oh yea that's because I have fact to back things up, but that's okay tomorrow you will be under oath I just might have to wake up early to come watch you squirm.

Al resigned for personal family reasons and had been the county attorney since June of '09, so over a year and a half, but you would have known that since you are so up on what is going on in the county.

You claim not to know your Sugar Daddy JD and Pimp Chuckle "Mark Mywords" Bunch and you might not in person, but you sure must be in communication with them because you tend to repeat exact same bile that they do. Plus, they even give you credit in another topic on this forum for information. Things that make you go hmmmmmmm.

You claim not to know Joe, yet you claim to be the one that told him how to get his rights restored? You wouldn't recognize Joe, but you don't go to meetings because you don't want to watch his circus? You claim not to hate Joe, but proclaim his simple appointment as the sole failure of the new commission deeming them worse then any commission before. That looks like a huge contradiction from here.

You claim you don't like being sued or lied about, then why have you been lying? If you don't know Joe, don't hate Joe, didn't love Jimmy why for years have you been attacking Joe has he stood against the Jimmy's? Why have you lied and made liable statements about him that would cause you to be sued? Looks to me like you brought it on yourself.

You claim that Joe has cost the taxpayers money, other then his one just lawsuit, how has he cost the county money. What you should be complaining about is Charles Bunch costing the county money with his frivolous lawsuit and now Linda Kimbel with her's which is exactly what it is frivolous also.

Oh and while I'm here I'm not trying to take any posters away from this forum, is there a law that says you can only post on one. I know there are some subjects and language John doesn't like, plus I know he doesn't want PM's so my Private Site allows that. It looks to me that you're coming over hear now because with us feeding the truth over there that it has now died.

This is the point where on Topix you would now go into a personal attack on me since you can't dispute what I said, so sorry you can't do that on this forum, so if you are going to reply why not start with the truth for once.

The Kimbels didn't have a Lawyer, at the time. And yes, you are wrong. Mr. Ward has been a Lawyer long enough to know what is ethical for him to do & long enough to know that what he did wouldn't even be questioned by anybody who has the slightest idea of what they're talking about.